What is Graymail?

Definition

Graymail refers to emails users once signed up for but rarely open now. These messages come from legitimate sources, like newsletters or promotional lists, but no longer feel relevant to the recipient. Unlike spam, graymail includes content that the user initially opted into but now often ignores. It sits somewhere between desired mail and unwanted junk—hence, graymail.

Example

Here is an example: a customer subscribes to an online store’s newsletter to get updates and sales offers. For a while, they open and read each email. But over time, they lose interest. They do not unsubscribe, but they start ignoring the messages. The emails are not spam, but they are not engaging the subscriber anymore. That is graymail.

Why Is Graymail Different from Spam?

Graymail differs from spam in one key way: permission. While spam arrives without consent from unknown senders, graymail comes from sources that the recipient approved. Spam clutters inboxes with irrelevant or suspicious content. Graymail, on the other hand, is legitimate content that’s simply just no longer interesting.

ISPs treat these email types differently, too. Spam filters block unwanted, unsolicited emails to protect users from scams. Graymail isn’t blocked but may be sent to the “Promotions” or “Updates” folders. This keeps graymail accessible without clogging up the recipient’s primary inbox.

Strategies to Manage Graymail

Here are some strategies to help manage graymail:

• Segment your lists carefully. Group active and inactive subscribers separately. Send targeted content to each group based on their engagement level. Adjust content as interests shift.
• Run re-engagement campaigns. Use special offers, discounts, or reminders to reconnect with inactive subscribers. Try asking for feedback to see why interest dropped. This can help you tailor future content.
• Allow easy opt-outs. Make sure users can easily unsubscribe. This keeps your list fresh and focused, improving engagement and lowering complaints. A simple unsubscribe link also enhances user trust.
• Adjust your email frequency. Sometimes sending fewer emails keeps readers more engaged. Test lower frequencies to see if this boosts opens and clicks. Too many emails can drive disinterest.
• Track engagement closely. Pay attention to which subscribers open and click through. Remove contacts who show no interest over time to improve list quality. Regular monitoring keeps your list active.

Using these strategies helps control graymail, keeping your list healthier and more focused on engaged readers. Fewer ignored emails mean better deliverability, cleaner data, and stronger email campaigns.

Related terms

• Email Deliverability Rate
• Email List Fatigue
• Unsubscribe Rate
• List Hygiene

Related articles

• How To Improve Email Deliverability
• Email Marketing Metrics to Track
• Email Deliverability: 101 Guide